Thu 15 Nov 2007
Well, I promised. The problem with mistakes is that I am still making them and I am blinded to my own shortcomings. If most of the things that irritated me had to do with commonsense most of my own failings came in the form of pride. But here we go, not in order of importance. It is not a pretty picture and it has been painful to think about.
Here are the mistakes I know about I am sure they are only tip of the iceberg:
1. When I first had babies I pridefully went to church, sometimes within hours of having the baby. With my natural parenting approach I didn’t see any need to sit at home when I had only had a baby and that wasn’t a disease. It wasn’t until my last 2 that I began to understand how important it is for a mother to separate herself from the world in order to protect her baby from germs and to enable proper nursing and proper healing. A new baby needs to be protected from too much stimulation and believe me my babies got plenty of stimulation at home. Staying away from activities or church for 6 weeks isn’t too long.
2. I overfed my firstborn. I nursed him every time he had any kind of emotion. Thankfully, none of my children were colicky in spite of the over-feeding. I chalk that up to not using a pacifier. I tried to use a pacifier but gave up. I never gave up what is sometimes erroneously termed demand feeding, nor do I regret that. I just learned to not nurse the baby at the first sign of discomfort. I learned to stretch things out a bit. Both mothers who are avid schedulers and mothers who are intense demand-feeders like I was need common sense. Both approaches will work with a little common sense on the part of the mother but neither is successful in the hands of a ninny.
3. I deeply regret trying to schedule my 4th son after being told not scheduling him was rebellion on my part. I knew enough to know that my heart was rebellious but not enough to know that demand feeding was not a contributor. That child cried for 9 months until I stopped the schedule at 9 months. He hasn’t made a peep since.
4. I regret taking it personal when some of my older children had trouble learning to read. We all laugh now at how mad I got at a certain child every single day but I am not really proud of that episode. I am ashamed that the schooling of my children was a pride issue for me. Yes, I lost my temper a lot in the early years. When a more recent child struggled learning to read I hardly noticed at all.
5. In my desire not to be one of THOSE mothers, I always punished my children when other people complained about them. Later I wished that they had also seen that I was on their team and that I was rooting for them. Last year my oldest son, who knew I felt bad about that, told me that if I was going to err he was glad I had erred on that side and not created the monsters he was seeing in the Navy, young people whose mamas always took their side. This calls for discretion. I didn’t have it.
6. I regret that I was over zealous all the time. I think it deadened my children to spiritual things to hear about them all the time everyday. “The best lack all conviction while the worst are full of passionate intensity.” I wince every time I read that line.
7. I regret that I was harder on my children than I was on myself.
8. I didn’t realize that hard-working even overly-worked homeschooled geniuses who obeyed on command could be spoiled. I let my boys talk me in and out of way too many things for their own good. And they were smart enough to do it subtly enough to stay under my radar. It was years later before I realized how often I had been swayed by the logic of my sons. I hadn’t learned to say, “Phooey,” yet. This is still a hard one for me.
9. Perhaps the biggest mistake was the feeling that if I just did everything “right” my children would be some sort of new breed never before seen in the history of the world. Unfortunately, I judged older parents by this high standard. The problem is that people I listened to were teaching this. My husband was not deluded for nearly as long as I was which kinda made me mad at him for awhile. The good news is that I learned from my mistake and I am very good at spotting false parenting assumptions and bad teaching. The sad thing is that I know a lot of families who did not survive this mistake. Perhaps you are thinking this was a personal failing and not a parenting mistake. Well, it was a personal failing based on pride but it also was very, very hard on the children and probably damaged them more than anything else. I was setting them up either to fail or become so prideful there was no hope for them outside of a failing.
10. I didn’t avoid the homeschooling trap of over-familiarity with my children which undermined my authority and confused the children.
I have said it lots of time here on this blog but I thought I was the potter and the children were the clay. I was deeply shocked when my oldest joined the Navy. I never once thought of the military as an option not having been around it. When I say shocked I mean absolutely lost. I didn’t have a clue what I was doing anymore. How was I supposed to raise my children when all the while God was shaping them into something different than what I was shaping?
In the end, of course, that became my comfort.
I am not the potter! I am not the potter ! Ding, dong the witch is dead.
Hallelujah, The Lord God Omnipotent Reigns!
53 Comments
RSS feed for comments on this post.
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

Again, you challenge me.
No doubt there will be a gazillion comments on this post and IHC will not rate. But my heart fails not
People love the negativity and the word mistake in the title will grab their attention. As it did mine.
I admire your generosity with your time for bringing up this topic and moderating all the comments.
So, for the benefit of my children, I will contemplate my regrets and work on a list.
But in the meantime, I headed to the grocery store
Comment by Dana (November 15, 2007 @ 7:55 am )
Dana,
I only have so much time and I will not be spending another week like this one. I only wrote the post because a girl in the comments asked me to.
Comment by Cindy (November 15, 2007 @ 7:57 am )
Cindy, I usually don’t comment, but I am amazed at this post. You said some things that I’ve never really heard anyone say! Deep down I have felt guilty about #6, feeling like I had not done enough, so it is a blessing to hear you say it’s okay to lighten up. As for the others, I’m pretty much in agreement, and most of them I also had to learn the hard way. #1, #3, and #7 I avoided only because I am too lazy. And #10? Oh, my. I think you have finally identified one of my biggest problems. I have really been struggling with something, and I think this is IT. But how in the world do you climb out of this mess once you’ve gotten there? Do you still battle this, or have you managed to reverse it? Over-familiarity…I’m going to have to think long and hard about this one!
Comment by homefire (November 15, 2007 @ 8:04 am )
Thank you, Cindy. Tears come to my eyes as I read some of these. I cannot tell you how God has used you in my life to slowly teach me some of these things. I am so far from what I want to be and what God wants me to be. But, I am thankful that God sent you in my life to frequently whisper such things. I have a shelf full of parenting books. And I know wonderful families. And I was looking for that magical formula. I have learned some wonderful ideas; but, it is such a relief to know that it is not all about me. I am never going to be a good enough mother to raise perfect children! What an idea! I mean, I am far from perfect. God is not finished with me yet. Why would I think I could raise perfect children? Thank you so much for a breath of fresh air in the midst of much pressure that I often feel.
Comment by Laura (November 15, 2007 @ 8:34 am )
I am printing this one before there are 100 comments!
Comment by Laura (November 15, 2007 @ 8:35 am )
The only thing that makes this post tolerable is that it is Cindy pointing the finger at herself. I cringe for her, because I dont want her to admit her regrets so publically. But I guess she’s allowed.
I am saddled with the burden of that offensive trait *It’s not what you say but how you say it* aka the tone in my voice. So, I really try to refrain from giving advice to youngers. It never comes out right.
In my younger days, I relied heavily on Bruce Ray’s parenting book, Withhold Not Correction, and was particularly convicted by the chapter on prayer. I still regret the lack of attention to my prayer life.
As Spurgeon urges…
As artists give themselves to their models, and poets to their classical pursuits, so must we (Christians) addict ourselves to prayer.
And now, I reallly am going to the grocery store.
Blessing fm GA,
Dana
Comment by Dana (November 15, 2007 @ 8:36 am )
I asked for this post. It is an honest list, and encouraging to me.
Comment by Michelle (November 15, 2007 @ 8:42 am )
Dana,
I have been thinking of prayer all morning and I wish I had said something in the post about it. When all is said and done it is our number 1 tool.
Y’all are making me feel a lot better. I hope that this post is a post that points to the gospel as our hope.
Comment by Cindy (November 15, 2007 @ 8:48 am )
I agree with the prayer issue. If I could do one thing over (and there are many I would like to do over)it would be that I’d pray and pray and pray for my children rather than thinking it was all up to me, armed with my little child discipline books. Yes, we are to obey God concerning the raising of our children, but we are only dust and unable to even take a breath without Him. Thank God it is not all up to us!
Thank you, Cindy. I know it’s hard to dwell on all those things. Thank you particularly for #9. We all need to hear that, young and old moms alike! (”But Lord, I HOMESCHOOLED them; I CLASSICALLY homeschooled them; my daughters wore only dresses; we baked all our own bread; we NEVER put them in a nursery or in Sunday school; we read all (fill in the blank’s) book; we never watched TV and we listened only to Bach!” At some point in my mothering, I’ve had each of those proud thoughts swirling through my head. Praise God, none of my children have gone astray, but it’s not due to any of those things!
Comment by Linda (November 15, 2007 @ 9:30 am )
Your final paragraph was my favorite.
I pridefully thought I was the potter.
I know now, that I am not.
Comment by Miz Booshay (November 15, 2007 @ 9:38 am )
Cindy,
It was a surprise to read your post today - while I taking a shower this morning (before I read your post) I was thinking about my oldest son (who is sprouting his wings and moving on into adulthood). I was thinking how hard of a time I have had letting him do this at times. His choices aren’t wrong - they are just different from what I would have chosen (he hasn’t said Navy yet, for which I am thankful - although given his personality and desires it would not surprise me). I was thinking about all the control I have had over his life from what he studies, to his activities and even his friends and how hard it is to give that up (and realizing I wasn’t even in control anyway.) I think as homeschoolig parents we do have so much more control over our children and then when they are ready to move on, boy has it been a shock. Part of me wants him to be 5 again so I can tell him what to do, but that’s not what God has given him to me for. Anyway then to get on here and read your post!! I think I’ll post “I am not the potter” on my bathroom mirror. Thanks for being so honest - it is quite an encouragement.
Comment by Kim (November 15, 2007 @ 10:16 am )
This is an inspiring list- by which I mean a list that I think inspires us all to be humble and introspective.
I don’t think I have the intelligence to come up with such a great list, but it’s not because I didn’t make equal- or greater- mistakes.
Numbers 1 and 2 were so totally me. My first child was colicky and we did use a pacifier- except I was the pacifier. I did believe that every noise she made meant I needed to feed her again. She ate at least every 90 minutes and for at least 30 minutes each time. She was fat, dimply, fussy, and she threw up constantly. Our sixth child was much the same in temperament and physical tendencies, and with her I learned to stretch out that 90 minutes to at least two hours and then longer ( I am not a ‘let the baby cry’ person, I distracted her to stretch those times) and she quit throwing up and was a much happier baby. People tell you breastfed babies cannot over-eat, and that is simply not true.
One other thing I still struggle with, especially in finding the right balance, is in the proper handling of a ‘bad influence,’ whether that is a person, an idea, a game, a movie, a book, a song, or too much sugar. Sometimes that influence really does just need removing from my child’s life or mine. Sometimes all the bad influence is really doing is drawing out an infection so I can see it and I need to deal more with the inward issue and worry less about the outward. Sometimes it’s both, but the proportions vary, and most often I worry too much about whether I am getting them precisely right (that potter/clay thing).
I tend to want a black and white approach, an either/or- but one is too legalistic and one is too unrealistic.
Comment by DeputyHeadmistress (November 15, 2007 @ 10:31 am )
Thanks for your honesty- these posts on parenting have been so good!
Praises be to our high King- His hands shape us better than we ever could!
Comment by Heather (November 15, 2007 @ 10:41 am )
DHM,
I didn’t put down sheltering too much or sheltering too little as mistakes because I don’t know which one I erred on. Now isn’t that a doosey?
We are still constantly battling that sort of thing. Twice this week I have had personal friends talk to me about young people their young people were around that frustrated the parent and in both situations I was with the parent. If ideas have consequences then we must pay attention to these things but do we pay attention to them by being hyper-controlling or do we pay attention by keeping up a running dialog like you mentioned about your daughter in her poetry. Sometimes it is one and sometimes the other but I hardly know which?
“the headlines read these are the worst of times….
I do believe its true…”
Can’t you just feel the harmony?
I’m just teasing you, old friend, and besides I own that song and I even like it.
Comment by Cindy (November 15, 2007 @ 10:42 am )
Cindy PLEASE BE VERY, VERY PROUD of that son in the Navy!!! He is doing something so very important and great really. I come from a tradition of that (father, brothers and myself) and I respect the military a lot, it does an important job.
I wish I had a son who had gone into the military, I’d be proud beyond belief.
From the perspective on one with no kids it looks to me overall like these faults are not much, you’re kids probably aren’t complaining and they seem to be assets to the world and that is pretty good, better than most.
A son in the Navy, I’d never stop talking about it, LOL!
Comment by Cassandra (November 15, 2007 @ 11:00 am )
#9 is a good reminder for me. My children aren’t old enough for me to see my fruits yet, but in the past I am ashamed to say I used the same logic to judge a marriage. As if one spouse could be perfect and that would be enough. As if they could do everything right and the fact that the other was sinful wouldn’t matter. I think that is something I am learning in the marriage area, and I’m hoping I will apply it to my children, also…the admission that all have sinned (including me) and that none of us will ever be perfect enough to play the part of redeemer.
This is why I like the idea of forbearance…
Thank you for the reality check, Cindy.
Comment by Brandy (November 15, 2007 @ 11:17 am )
I thought you were still on sabbatical, but Kathleen linked to you about an article.
I think I could have written this one. It’s funny how we go through similar stages in the Christian walk. If we don’t fall in one ditch, we fall off in the other, but I remind myself that I learned sooooo much in those ditches.
Parenting as an older person is indeed much more relaxing. I laugh more than I ever did with my oldest two. I was reading a bit futher down the page a moment ago and remembering feeling guilty that I didn’t have time to do all that hands-on artsy/craftsy stuff. I’ve also found that reading (fiction and non-fiction) to them is a springboard into creative playtime. They take legos or cardboard and make their own viking ships, volcanos or whatever after “school” is done. They make terrific messes, but it takes less time to clean it up (with them working too) than I would have spent planning, setting it up, and “teaching”.
Take care! ~Sandy
Comment by Sandy (November 15, 2007 @ 11:20 am )
hey there cindy,
love this post.. thanks for the conversation the other day, I’m looking forward to seeing God work here. This stage of growth in our children’s lives can be pretty challenging just as well as those younger years were. Whoa, have we made mistakes too and sometimes it’s good to be reminded that “the mercies of the Lord are new every morning” Lamentations 3:22. It’s the Lord who does the work inspite of our failures and shortcomings and we know that we can have all of our ‘ducks’ lined up but it’s the Lord who allows them to sink or swim, and not because we’ve done it all correctly.
take care
Comment by Terri (November 15, 2007 @ 11:24 am )
This is so great–thank you for taking a week of your life to read a million comments. I wish that I never “forgot” (but I forget all the time) the truth of the last paragraph about God shaping, God discipling, God caring for our kids and moms not being the potter. And it is a consolation to know that what is initially shocking becomes one’s very comfort. Because the gospel itself is shocking, and if I gut the shock from it I lose all the comfort too. It is an encouragement to hear from an older wiser mom that I will still be shocked, and still comforted by the gospel when mine are grown. I want more guidance and elaboration on #6 but I know you have a real life to return to! Thank you!
Comment by Emily (November 15, 2007 @ 11:53 am )
Just a couple of thoughts…colicky babies don’t come from pacifiers. Maybe some do, but that’s not the case in our house, so I know it can’t be a general principle.:-) As far as what has been said about breast-feeding all the time (ala DHM), and overeating–what happened to us was that the kids would wake up at night every three hours and nurse, but then during the day, they’d have stretched out to six hours or so. I tried to “force feed” more during the day so that they’d go longer at night, but that didn’t work and in the end, I had to make them go longer at night.
Comment by Patti (November 15, 2007 @ 12:07 pm )
Sandy,
I think some of that “arts and crafts” stuff is over-rated. I think there’s limited value in it (as opposed to real hobbies of knitting, sewing, etc. when they’re older). It actually seems so very artificial now to me. I did let my kids have free reign with paints, scissors, glue, and construction paper–so they could do whatever they wanted with them, but after awhile gave up on the more structure arts and crafts ideas.
Comment by Patti (November 15, 2007 @ 1:29 pm )
Cindy–this post was so… brave. I have spent all morning composing my own list in my head and got to about three before my nerve failed me.
Yet, I am encouraged.
Comment by lady laura (November 15, 2007 @ 1:45 pm )
Wow again! I feel like I am looking into a mirror. I can’t really stand back and judge how I am doing on 8, 9, and 10. I have been dealing wiht the fact, these last couple of years, that I am not the potter. It scares me to death, but I suppose it should bring great relief. At times it does… It’s hard to let go of the control of the unknown when my life’s work is at stake. LOL It’s hard not to be able to see what the end product is going to be or even really where we’re headed! I guess that’s where obedience, faith and trust come in.
Comment by another Brandy (November 15, 2007 @ 1:54 pm )
Thank you for being so candid. I find myself (shamefully and honestly) in many of those you listed, and my kids are just 7, 5, and 4. I need to LAY OFF in some areas…thank you for this reminder.
You’re brave, witty, wonderful…this is why I love your blog!
Comment by Lindsey @ enjoythejourney (November 15, 2007 @ 2:28 pm )
Thanks for doing these.
Some advice on HOW to pray for our children or resource recommendations would be helpful.
Comment by sara (November 15, 2007 @ 3:27 pm )
Thank you, Cindy. Excellent post.
Comment by Carol in Oregon (November 15, 2007 @ 7:01 pm )
I just had to come back and praise Cindy for her wise words. I just hope she hasnt given her children too much fodder.
Surely they rise up and already call her blessed.
Furthermore, I’ll bet her list of things she doesnt regret is a lot longer than these ten things.
Comment by Dana (November 15, 2007 @ 7:45 pm )
Dana,
This has been a rough week and I am so happy you are faithful. I thought about a post of things that worked and I remember reading the Bruce Ray book years ago. I think those were simpler times and that book was so straightforward and clear. I hardly know how a book like that would go over now.
I think there are a lot of dangers in a post like this. I had to be very careful not to cause pain to my children in relating my mistakes and I am not totally sure that I succeeded.
And while I believe in being humble and you may have been joking, I still think we don’t have to let our children know all of our shortcomings. We don’t need to give the enemy an opportunity to plant bad ideas in their hearts.
I am listening to you, Dana. I am reading your heart and I am so thankful for your words.
I have been very encouraged this week by the mothers who have linked here. I don’t quite understand how one group of women can say this has been an encouraging series of posts and another group (not age groups) are greatly offended.
I really wonder what women are doing on the Internet and I am deeply disturbed.
Comment by Cindy (November 15, 2007 @ 10:33 pm )
Cindy,
Thank you SO much for publishing this series of posts. I greatly appreciate your transparency as well as that of many of your commenters. I am a “young” mother in the sense that my children are young–8 & 5–& while I don’t agree with some of the various “thou shalt nots”
I have given/am giving thoughtful consideration to them. As I read I am finding that I need to really examine why I disagree & if I should change or if some of these areas of disagreement merely represent differences in mama personalities/child personalities/parenting styles.
I always look forward to your posts each day!
Thank you for the encouragement & edification,
Serena
Comment by Serena (November 15, 2007 @ 11:40 pm )
Cindy, This series of posts has blessed me so much. Thank you for doing this. I have linked.
Comment by Myfriendconnie (November 15, 2007 @ 11:48 pm )
sara,
Amy @ HumbleMusings.com has written a lovely post onHow to Pray for Our Children.
Comment by Connie P (November 16, 2007 @ 3:18 am )
Thanks for your honesty and humility–what a thoughtful, provocative post. Gives me a lot to chew on. I’d be interested to hear you expound more on #6, if you’re willing. I had never heard of or thought of such a thing and I could see myself tending to be overzealous like that. I’m also not sure if I quite understand the “line that makes you wince.”
Thanks also for the reminder who the Potter is. Your second to last line made me smile
Comment by Amy (November 16, 2007 @ 11:31 am )
Amy,
The line is from William Butler Yeats’ poem The Second Coming.
If we are always so intense about everything how will our children know what is really important?
One of our family stories is that my oldest went to SS when he was 5 and all the children were talking about the movie Ghostbusters. He told his class,” My mama says that movie is a sin against God.”
I didn’t ever remember saying any such thing but the fact is I very well could have.
On Pamela’s blog a mother said she was so afraid her children would go astray that she only wanted to listen to parents who had 100% success rates. I was very much like that young woman.
Say that you rail and your rail with your children about all kinds of things: drugs and rock music and Christian music and weak Christianity and sugar and white bread and recycling and ‘those’ people and bad literature and mud on their boots and dirty houses and vaccinations and feeding babies and chocolate and vitamins and natural childbirth, how will your children know which of these things is really important? Maybe one day they find out that some Christians eat sugar and they are nice lovely people who truly love the Lord but from hearing you day in and day out he thought that anyone who ate sugar had a free ticket to hell. Now every single thing you have tried to teach your child ever has been undermined by your passionate intensity.
Save the passion for the things that matter, use discussion to deal with the rest. Speak honestly to your children. If you don’t know which music is God’s music and which is the Devil’s but some music bothers you, tell them you are bothered; tell the why but do not tell them that you know exactly where God draws the line. You can tell them point blank that you are not going to let them listen to certain music but don’t close the door on communication by your passionate intensity and sureness.
Comment by Cindy (November 16, 2007 @ 11:57 am )
Thanks for taking the time to follow-up. That makes total sense. I think maybe I didn’t fully understand your original statement…I thought you meant “hearing spiritual things all the time” as in “relating the gospel to all of life, talking about Jesus constantly, etc.” That’s why I was surprised to think of that as a negative thing. Now I see that you meant, making every point of conviction a passionate, spiritual matter–and I can see how that would end up undermining everything you were passionate about. Thanks for the clarification!
Comment by Amy (November 16, 2007 @ 12:20 pm )
Thanks for this post. I would love it if you wrote an entire post on #10, because I see what you are saying is true, but I would love more advice about it.
Sometimes the advice of older women collides. I followed the advice of my mom (and the pediatrician)when my children were born and kept my newborns home from church for weeks during the cold and flu season. Our pastor’s wife intensely disapproved and actually believed I was breaking my church vows.
Comment by Melissa Hindman (November 16, 2007 @ 2:50 pm )
Melissa,
I can’t help you with conflicting advice. It has always been that way and always will be. You just need to pray for wisdom and try to be kind when someone doesn’t understand your choices. The key is too follow what you believe God would want you to do without getting all self-righteous about it. You don’t sound self-righteous but many of my own mistakes were in that area.
About the over-familiarity. It is when you joke and play and tease with your children so much they don’t know when they have crossed the line into disrespect and usually you don’t see it at first either.
My dad was a college baseball coach and he always said that as much as he would liked to been friends with his players, he couldn’t be and have a good team. He had to be the absolute authority. Now if you knew my dad you would know he isn’t a chest-beater but he kept his distance from his players until after they had graduated. Many of his former players are his friends now.
We are so tempted to be friends with our children and in some senses we are. But then there is a line of authority that has to be maintained and being together so much makes it harder to draw that line.
Comment by Cindy (November 16, 2007 @ 3:17 pm )
I’ve LOVED your series, Cindy. It is plain to see (to me) that you have not meant to offend, but were just being humorous. (And there was much to learn in the post AND the comment section.) I am troubled, sometimes, by what I see as an unwillingness to learn by those who are easily offended.
This is a hard thing about blogging. Eventually, you will offend everyone - whether you intend to or not.
I believe, though, that you have blogged some wonderful advice for fellow mothers of all ages.
Comment by Holly (November 16, 2007 @ 9:30 pm )
Thank you, Cindy, for sharing your heart and being vulnerable. My faults are many, but the over-familiarity one makes me stop and think. I’m not sure how to do it differently being I am home with my children, all day, everyday. How would you do it differently?
Comment by Roberta (November 16, 2007 @ 11:26 pm )
Cindy,
I also read the comment on Pamela’s blog about only seeking advise from parents with the 100% success rate. We are SO off when we believe raising children (or educating them) is all about methodology. We are not in a factory making plastic. It is not as though if we simply follow the recipe we will have a particular product at the end. Our children aren’t merely clay in our hands. As you already stated, we are NOT the potter. I can think of a couple of mothers who are tormented by their grown children not walking in a way they ought to. No matter how well their other children may be doing they live under a cloud of shame and agony of wondering what they did wrong. I think parenting is much more like farming…we prepare the soil, plant the seeds and care for the crops but in the end the results are always in God’s hands. There is a true cause and effect in raising our children, and scripture directs us in what we ought to do. But at the end of the day, it really is a mystery. This is a humbling thought that ought to both alarm and comfort us. We ought to strive to be godly in our parenting and be so very grateful to God if our children, as adults, walk in a manner pleasing to Him. To Him alone be the glory.
Sue
Comment by Sue (November 17, 2007 @ 12:09 am )
Thank you Cindy for elaborating for Amy in #33 b/c I had the same question and now I think I understand more of what you are saying. In Calvin’s institutes in the Freedom chapter he says that Christian freedom is freedom from torment over things indifferent. I think I have trouble discerning what is indifferent and what isn’t and so I am sometimes tormented over things that don’t matter. I need to pray for discernment I guess.
Comment by Emily (November 17, 2007 @ 11:58 am )
Wow. What a post. Thanks for sharing your heart.
Comment by Christie (November 17, 2007 @ 3:46 pm )
thank you for this series, i have been reading and wading through comments all week and dont have much to add. as a young mom i know i am a mess at some things, figuring this all out can be hard, ya know!? but thank you especially for this candid and real list.
#1 really spoke to me. when my boys were born, i felt like i had it REALLY together if i was up and about, going to church, or to book club or the store quickly after they were born. like, somehow this proved my coping ability- like i had this motherhood thing all figured out. who was i kidding besides myself!? i seriously believed though, unintentionally, that my ability to cart my babes around somehow translated into my abilty to be supermom.
it is such a steep learning curve…thank you for you wisdom and insight.
Comment by anya* (November 17, 2007 @ 8:29 pm )
I appreciated all you wrote here. Your recognition of your flaws tells me you are, indeed, a good mother. Your children will - if they haven’t already - rise up and call you blessed.
Comment by Donna-Jean (November 18, 2007 @ 12:59 am )
Thank you for this wonderful post! My dd is only 7, so I have a long way to go. But, thanks for telling me that “I am not the potter!” I really need to let that sink in…
Comment by Dana (November 18, 2007 @ 10:41 am )
Thank you for this post! It is startling to see myself so clearly in some of them. And some of them are not mine, but I could add others, that’s for sure.
I wish you would’ve posted this either before or with your list of “hates”. It would have made it more palatable. I’m sorry to bring that up again, but I really still have a hard time associating the word “hate” with light-heartedness, however you may have intended it. I did not feel defensive after reading the list, b/c I’m only guilty of cutting off crusts for a child who can’t chew the homemade bread crusts. Just don’t like the “h” word for the sake of young moms out there.
Comment by Lisa W. (November 19, 2007 @ 4:51 pm )
I think number nine is the one I would make.
Comment by covenantedliberty (November 19, 2007 @ 6:36 pm )
I should say MOST likely make, as I am likely to fall into them all; and many besides.
Comment by covenantedliberty (November 19, 2007 @ 6:37 pm )
Wow! Thank you Cindy for your honesty. I think some of your follow up comments have a lot to do with the posts on convictions that I’m planning to write.
Thanks again.
Comment by Meredith B. (November 20, 2007 @ 5:20 pm )
As a young lady currently only considering marriage and (hopefully) motherhood, I just wanted to tell you what an encouragement this list is to me! There’s something about humility, isn’t there, that just makes us want to draw close and learn more!
I’ve been disheartened sometimes by the attitudes of some older ladies at my church, particularly some of those I was paired with in the nursery; while our church is certainly blessed with many ladies I always feel I can approach, and whose example I hope to one day emulate in my own home, there are also those ones who seemed to take their experience not as licence to teach and admonish, but to ride roughshod over women younger than they. I was in a position to see what harm their lectures did to the eagerness and hopefulness of the young mothers whose children I looked after, and it broke my heart even before I quite understood how awful it must have felt to be on the receiving end of that manner of advice.
Your balance of humble honesty and good hearted advice is such a treat!
Comment by Andrea (November 25, 2007 @ 9:43 am )
Oh — I think I’m making this mistake.
I sooo want to know how to develop in my children the desire to love the Lord and serve Him with all their might.
How do I get rid of the rolling of the eyes, or the evil tones? Oh — you don’t know how I long for this. Happy loving children…
Comment by ~*~ Jennifer ~*~ (November 27, 2007 @ 9:49 am )
Okay, I know I’m weighing in way late on this one but I just have to tell you Cindi that I dont get what all the hoopla is about this post. Why would people be offended? I just cant grasp that! I mean its not like you are talking about someone else. You’re speaking of your mistakes and God knows every parent has made them.
I usually fnd that those who have the most answers to raising children are those who have no idea of their end product. The mothers of toddlers had much to tell me when my last one was small. They forgot that I had already raised a child to adulthood.
My criteria for parenting advice is that the person has to have grown children. It matters not to me whether all those children have turned out perfectly. It matters only that the person has been through the entire process.
Thats why I love your advice. You’ve been there and done that.
This was a great post!!!
Comment by mrs darling (November 27, 2007 @ 11:45 am )
Mrs Darling,
You are my faithful friend. Thank-you!
Comment by Cindy (November 27, 2007 @ 12:18 pm )
Thank you for these encouraging words from an older mom. As a young mom (age 32–3 kids, 5 & under), I struggle with my feelings of inadequacy as well as intense pressure that I put on myself. It’s kind of nice to know that others do or have felt this way & messed up many times along the way. And that’s ok because God is sovereign and his grace will cover my multitude of sins.
Comment by sara (November 27, 2007 @ 8:07 pm )